The Thought I Keep Coming Back To
Of all these examples, the movie conversation stays with me. You’d think the person who saw the movie had the advantage. Then someone who hasn’t seen it tells you more about the characters than you can. You can still object that they missed the music and the actors’ faces. But now you owe them a scene, a pause, or a sound without which they got something wrong. Otherwise it’s a pretty easy victory for the viewer over the person who remembers the plot better.
We’re more generous with our own memories than with a machine’s. If a person gets a book, a calendar, and the chance to ask again, let’s see what happens when the agent gets access to its notes, too. Sometimes the difference we saw disappears. Sometimes it turns out we were interested in a different ability all along. Remembering the date of a meeting and spending the day waiting for it really are different things.
My biggest questions still go back to that first urge to pick up Pelevin. With an agent we can identify the event that woke it. Have we explained why it chose the book? Not yet. And with someone who says “I just felt like it,” we don’t even have a record of the event. That’s where I’d like to pick up the conversation.